dsgrue3 on 29 January 2013
| timmah said: There you go again with (not so) veiled attacks on my intellect, you keep it classy. By the way, your 'up' is actually 'down' to people in China :P. |
It's frustrating when you keep returning to time doesn't apply, then when I say time isn't relevant you say logic doesn't apply. Logic applies to anything and everything. It's two concepts that are contradictory to each other. Those being omniscience and free will.
Free will implies choice and nondeterminism. This isn't debatable. This is by definition.
Omniscience implies determinism (since nothing is unknown).
Nondeterminism != determinism
Simple, no other aspects need be considered at all. Time, Space, God, Human, does not matter. It is simply logic based purely on definition.
