By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
timmah said:

Yes, yes, because your opinion is absolute truth and your logic is completely infallable. Got it.

Keep in mind, the 'frozen river' analogy is neither provable nor purely logical based on our perspective of time, but that doesn't mean the person who wrote the book is stupid or illogical.

This isn't an opinion.

Free Will implies choice. If there is a deterministic path, there is no choice. They are contradictory concepts by definition. 

This isn't as complex as you seem to think it is.