Uncharted 3 vs Gears of War 3 (revisited)

[dsgrue3]

ninjablade said:

CGI-Quality said:

ninjablade said:

CGI-Quality said:

And still no sales data to back up anything you've said. Got it. 

like i said you can use common sense or you can be a fanboy, choose what ever you like, look at uncharted DF first 10 weeks  WW on a holiday season it sold less then a million, yet it magically did 4.5 million units if the game was not bundled it would have never seen 2.5 million.

Or I could use data, if I make claims. You've done no such thing and expect your arguments to hold water.

Go ahead and use data show me game that sold less then a million in its first 10 weeks and did 3 million, keep in mind uncharted DF did 4.5 million, i'm waiting.

Not quite what you asked, but Demon's Souls did under 100,000 in its first 10 weeks, and now rests at 1.67m. Sometimes games take a long time for people to be aware of them - UC:DF suffered from this as well.