Uncharted 3 vs Gears of War 3 (revisited)

[ninjablade]

CGI-Quality said:

ninjablade said:

dsgrue3 said:

ninjablade said:

i will always say this the best way to judge how big a franshise is by looking at the first 2 months of sales, first its offical numers and we an idea how many people will buy the game day 1 meaning that franshise is very important to them.

Okay.

 

UC2 - 10 weeks: 2.4m

UC3 - 10 weeks: 3.5m

Uncharted franchise is expanding in popularity by your own logic. Gears is too, just not as much:

GoW2 - 10 weeks: 4.3m

GoW3 - 10 weeks: 4.5m

Not sure why you don't think these games are comparable.

 

uncharted 2 is not even close, uncharted 3 is much closer but still has a huge advantage
 of being mass bundled, i'm not say there not comparable, i'm saying it not a fair comparson, i wanna point out again that almost every bundled game does amazing sales.

How is Uncharted 2 not close? I said I was done with you, because you ignore any argument that clears yours, but I really want to know how 6.08mill is not close to 6.58mill.

i was talking about the 10 weeks total,  mass bundled games easily get a 2 million in sales boost LTD sales, just look at forza 3 and LPB, those games would probably sold 3 million max.