Uncharted 3 vs Gears of War 3 (revisited)

[ZaneWane]

Mr Puggsly said:

pezus said:

DirtyP2002 said:
Uncharted and GT5 are the most bundled games this gen... well except for Nintendo franchises.
Uncharted 3 is bundled for its entire time on the market. So yeah, what an achievement. Kung Fu Panda did amazingly well in Xbox 360, too!

Is this a joke?

Kinect Adventures (pretty much every single sale from bundles)

Forza 3 (at least 2m from bundles alone)

And now MS has a holiday Forza 4 bundle like Sony has for Uncharted 3.

The fact that bundles with the game exist does not mean that the majority of its sales came from bundles, especially in Europe where you usually have lots and lots of different bundles.

What about Uncharted 2 then? Do you seriously think that Uncharted 3 was going to sell less than Uncharted 2 after the much more explosive start?

Edit: And the fact that you bring up Kung Fu Panda is a laughable attempt to belittle the sales of Uncharted.

Kinect Adventures is a pack in game. It was intended to only be sold as bundle software, bad example.

Forza 3 actually did over 3 million excluding bundles. It could have had better legs as well but Turn 10 can actually pump out a game in a reasonable amount of time.

If we're gonna pretend Uncharted sells at par with Gears, then I guess we should entertain those Kung Fu Panda numbers as well. Lego Batman as well.

truer words