By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
tastyshovelware said:
I've posted this stat before, as a gamerankings.com fan myself.

xbox 360 games that average 80% or higher: 87 (92 if you round up the 79.5+ scores)
............................................. 85% or higher: 36 (38 if you round up the 84.5+ scores)

ps3 games that average 80% or higher: 40 (41 if you round up nhl 2k7)
.................................... 85% or higher: 16

wii games that average 80% or higher: 18
................................... 85% or higher: 9

take from those number what you will.
(note: some games for each system only have 1 or 2 reviews currently posted. Some scores subject to change).

That includes XBLA titles, while not including Virtual Console titles... but either way, I think that shows the disconnect between reviewers and gamers very clearly.  If you asked a bunch of gamers which was better: Wii Sports or Virtua Tennis 3, what do you think they would say? 

Personally, I realized that reviews were meaningless when I played Final Fantasy XII... a game that averaged a 9.2, but I wouldn't rate above a 7.  A game that's by and large hated by the FF fanbase.