Your Top 50 Games: 2012 Discussion Thread: FINISH YOUR LISTS

[Smeags]

Hint for #4: This popular game introduced a new foe that was unseen afterwards until this very year thanks to a new sequel. The name of this foe happens to be shared by a crude teddy bear.

EDIT: Hm... seems this foe appeared in another game before this year, but in my defense he was in another dimension.