OneTwoThree on 22 December 2012
I thought DS, 7 and Wii were all great, but my favourite is still DD. Played it the most (closely followed by MKWii), very precise and rewarding over a long time. It's fast, the courses are tight, and the giant banana is a hilarious item. Plus the 2-player-mode was so much fun for my then girlfriend, she loved punching opponents off the track :)
Original, 64 and Super Circuit didn't age that well imo, their handling feels floaty and weird today. To be fair though, I didn't play MK64 when it was new, so I only know it as a retro game. Makes a big difference, I guess Mario64 isn't that much fun after Galaxy, too.
