Final Fantasy XIV. Best looking Final Fantasy, great artstyle and music. Game is abysmal. was like a 2-4/10 game when I played it. Hopefully I get into beta of reboot so I can assess again.
Uncharted 3. An okay game (6-7), but groundbreaking for it's animation etc and great graphics. Not a bad game.
LA Noire: Amazing Animation but like a 4/10 game.
El Shadai: Pretty, but a 4/10 game.
Mirrors Edge, an okay game with really great ideas but fails in executaion a (6-7) game, but amazing artyle and visuals on PC atleast.
All of these games get likea 1-2 point bonus from me because of how they look. Because Graphics do matter.