Neither. There should be a third choice.
I know people always bring out charts and comparisons but, to be honest, none of that makes much sense to me. Most launch conditions are unique, which means comparisons are normally worthless. A lot of devices that did well at launch went on to mediocre life-cycles. Likewise, some devices with poor initial sales were that way solely become of supply constraints. We've also evolved into a culture of brand loyalists, with many people buying products at launch simply because of the name-tag.
I'll be either impressed or unimpressed in January, when comparisons mean something. Even then, we still have some pivotal software releases waiting in the wings. Reaching a conclusion at this point seems incredibly premature.
