wfz on 10 December 2012
I voted for Twilight Princess. The first 2 trailers of the game were so widely different from the final product delivered, and it was a letdown in so many ways. The summary in your OP described my feelings very well. I would actually say Skyward Sword was an even BIGGER letdown (it actually makes me enjoy TP more..), but it wasn't an option on your list.
The Zelda franchise is my favorite video game franchise, too. :(
