By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

This idea people have that quality and enjoyability are less important criteria than length and price gives me chills. It feels like someone is telling me that "Twilight" is better than "The Old Man and the Sea" because it's longer.

As long as the category is "Game of the Year," then it should be open to ANY game. If people want to rearrange things into categories based on length and price then that's another thing entirely. However, if there are no inherent restrictions, then length and price should be non-factors.