Which console shaped this past gen the most?

[Jay520]

JayWood2010 said:

Yes Im aware that sony wanted a more realistic game, but it was Naughty Dog who came up with Uncharted not Sony.  And as I said other games does cinimatic games and has done it before uncharted.  It was being progressed before uncharted.  As I said, this is about consoles not games or developers.  This is just people showing bias opinions and yes Im looking at you on this too.

I'm confused, which of the following don't you agree with?:

1. Uncharted had a great impact on the gaming industry.

2. Without the PS3/Sony, Uncharted would not exist.

3. Therefore, without the PS3/Sony, there would never have been such a great impact on the industry.

4. The PS3/Sony were necessary for much of how the gaming industry has shaped.

Which of these don't you agree with? Yes, there has been cinematic games; I never said or implied that Uncharted was the first cinematic game. So, again, where from the above, is the disagreement coming from? 

You seem to agree with numbers 1-3, but you disagree with number 4. Why?