Ruh-Roh ... GameSpot Gives ZombiU A 4.5?

[Veknoid_Outcast]

the_dengle said:

VGKing said:

Veknoid_Outcast said:
Guys, guys, don't press the panic button. It's ONE review. Official Nintendo Magazine gave it a 92/100. We just can't go by one score. Why don't we wait for all the reviews to come in.

Of course it did.

If you can show me a game ONM scored 47 points above the meta, I'll be as cynical as you for a day.

It's starting to look like ZombiU is a divisive game, maybe around a 7-8, or anywhere from a 6-9 depending on your tastes, but 4.5 seems off.

This was my response to VGKing, but I might as well put it here since you touched on it.

Pandora's Tower
GameSpot: 8
IGN: 7
ONM: 7

The Last Story
GameSpot: 9
IGN: 8.5
ONM: 8.6

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
GameSpot: 7.5
IGN: 10
ONM: 9.8

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
GameSpot: 8.8
IGN: 9.5
ONM: 9.7

Super Mario Galaxy
GameSpot: 9.5
IGN: 9.7
ONM: 9.7

Cursed Mountain
GameSpot: 7.5
IGN: 7.5
ONM: 8.2

Wii Sports
GameSpot: 7.8
IGN: 7.5
ONM: 9

Fortune Street
GameSpot: 6
IGN: 7
ONM: 7.3

Epic Mickey
GameSpot: 6
IGN: 8
ONM: 8.5

Lost in Shadow
GameSpot: 7.5
IGN: 7.5
ONM: 7.3

Metroid: Other M
GameSpot: 8.5
IGN: 8.5
ONM: 9.1

Just Dance
GameSpot: 5.5
IGN: 2
ONM: 5

Hardly a comprehensive list, but not too shabby :)