| selnor said:
Without derailing the thread. To say Uncharted is not guilty of this as much as Halo 4 is pure wrong. Uncharted looks considerably better in cutscene or non controlled gameplay tan actual gameplay. Way moreso than Halo 4. It is far from CGI. The CGI in Halo 4 looks infinitely better than these shots. Hugely better. Uncharted if anything is more guilty. More disparity between cutscene and game in UC2 and 3 than Halo 4 cutscene - gameplay. And just because Halo 4 does look this good its unfair to call it out with absolutely no proof to your statement. If you play Halo 4 you will know its incredibly close the gameplay to its cutscenes. obviously some things do get changed. |
I called it out because it was 2560 x 1440 resolution, it had heavy anti-aliasing applied and it was a huge leap in graphical quality over the gameplay I've seen. Because of the anti-aliasing and draw distance, I also implied it was CGI in my first post, but I changed my mind after taking a closer look. I haven't seen the original shot from that cutscene, so I won't jump to conclusions as it could just be a pre-release bullshot, but from the shots I've seen of that cutscene, I think it's heavily pre-rendered.
I don't like it when people post pre-rendered shots of Uncharted 3 in graphical comparison threads (something which Aldro avoided I think).
Here's some comparison shots of cutscenes vs gameplay for Uncharted 3 and Halo 4. I tried to find similar scenes. If you want you can try and find better shots, wasn't sure where to look with Halo 4 and I didn't want to post shots with spoilers in.
Uncharted 3
Halo 4
