By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
AndrewWK said:
Barozi said:
Unless Dishonored or XCOM break the 90 barrier, I don't think they will become GOTY.

Realistically it's either Halo 4, Mass Effect 3 or Assassin's Creed 3


Dishonored has broken the 90´s barrier

http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/dishonored

No.

 

When you go to a site like Metacritic, you have to understand that the website does NOT take into account the reviews for each platform. There are SO many reviews for a Multigame that clearly states they tried on PS3 & 360, yet Meta for example adds it to the 360 instead of PS3 and vice versa sometimes.

 

GO from the version with the MOST reviews. I understand that theres a difference between versions, but Meta is NOT a good representative of that. Few sites does seperate reviews for PC and Consoles, especially for EACH GAME available. Based on the 360 which shows the most reviews => It has 89 Metacritic based upon 49 critics.

 

In the end, we use Meta to see what most outlets have given games and a rather.. odd score . So use the one with the most collective opinions...

 

Realisticly like mentioned: Mass Effect 3 is the only real nominee since the rest are all staggering around 87-90 (Diablo, Max Payne, Dishonored, Borderlands 2 etc).

 

Journey could be nominated, it depends wether they give a shit or not regarding PSN titles and so forth. But lets hope AC3 and Halo 4 are clear nominees like we all expect them to be (92+). But I am worried for AC3 for some reason. Halo 4 however: Not so much.