By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
d21lewis on 29 September 2012
Edit Thread
lilbroex said:
d21lewis said:
lilbroex said:
d21lewis said:
lilbroex said:
d21lewis said:

Rebel Strike was 95% space ships and explosions, though.  Humans looked pretty bad.  I know this is a comparison of power but whenever somebody brings up Rebel Strike in these things, it feels like comparing Forza to Uncharted.  Yeah, Forza looks great because it's just rendering cars.  A good looking X-Wing Fighter in a sparse environment seems like it would be easy to render.  We should find a comparison that is more "apples to apples" like RE4 vs RE Revelations or Rogue Squadron vs Star Fox 64 (Poor example.  Sorry.) or something

No, it wasn't. "All" of the human character in rebel strike were normal mapped as well as inside combat environment.

http://199.101.98.242/media/shots/66396-StarWars_Rebel_Strike-7.jpg

http://cdn3.spong.com/screen-shot/s/t/starwarsro98563/_-Rogue-Squadron-III-Rebel-Strike-_.jpg

It used accurate selfshadowing and dynamics lighting. Bloom lighitng. Desructive environments. Extremely detailed modals.

Hindsight is 20/20

 

Okayyy...whats your point? Its achievement have been dissected and documented many times as I just said.

Point is, for all of its achievements, it just doesn't look as good as we make it out to be--especially when it comes to the outside of the ship stuff.

 

Yes it does. You posted the worst low quality, eye cancer causing video you could find of the worst looking area you could find. If the maximum of a game achievement is locked to it worst looking area then that would make MGS4 an SD game.

Its like saying all of the doughnuts in a box arebad because one is mishapen. That video doesn't prove anything you just said. It just showed that not all area in the game were pushing the max that the console could do.

 

 

 

 

It did everything it was stated as doing.


Nah.  I just went to youtube and typed in "Rebel Strike Luke Skywalker Gameplay" and posted the first video that popped up.  I don't have any agenda against the game and I don't have a "3DS is better than Gamecube" agenda, either.  I watched like seven seconds of that video I posted, copied, and pasted it.

I posted the pic of my copy of Rebel Strike just to show that I've seen the game first hand so videos and screen shots aren't necessary.  I still stand by anything I posted.  There was a time when I would omit certain things and look for handpicked pics to prove my  point.  Now, I just call 'em like I see 'em.  To be honest, the original point of my first quote was to say that the best looking 3DS game and the game being compared to it on the Gamecube are just too different to give a fair comparison.  Nothing more.  Nothing less.