Mafia Round 46 - Realm of Darkness

[Linkzmax]

DarkThanatos said:

Linkzmax said:

Re-reading the end of night one though, DT stands out the most to me. First he said "I think we are making a mistake voting no lynch." here and soonafter, once the votes settled, he said "This is going to be a painful night. 2 lynch kills, mafia kill, maybe a vigilante kill, maybe a serial killer kill. " here. The night kills are inconsequential, because they should be expected no matter what. If he were a townie, he's saying we should have a lynch and his vote was on mario so he shouldn't have considered him town. He did say he did not believe zero was scum, but lynching one scum with a town isn't exactly painful. And even if he considered it as such, he could have voted no lynch to save zero. So that line suggests he already knew zero and mario weren't a part of his faction, and he just wanted to seem like a concerned townie.

This post is justifying why you are off track with your accusations of me. As i said, I think we are making a mistake voting no lynch, because  we needed a lynch to get some information, be it to find a scum, or as simple as just help cracking the DRM. By voting no-lynch, the information we would have got would have been the one that the Mafia would have given us, rather then what we as  a collected town wanted to find out. At the time I -along with many others- were very suspcious about Mario because he was playing badly etc. I did not consider him town, and rather then no-lynch I wanted Mario lynched. That's why I said we are making a mistake with no lynch. 

However I considered Zero to be almost certainly Town. He went against Mario's point about his role, and it was likely that he was Cop or Doctor because of this, as i thought Mario was mafia and fakeclaiming. I did not want Zero to be lynched because of this. Lynching one scum and a town power role cop/doctor in my eyes Is painful, because it could quite easily be just Mario. If I had removed my vote from Mario and voted no-lynch then Mario would have been saved -i thought he was scum- and voting no lynch would have still got just Zero lynched or it would have been no-lynch. Which I have already justified is a bad idea. 

So no. As I was stuck between either getting Zero lynched and Zero and Mario lynched, it was going to be a painful night.

If you want someone to be suspicious of look at Radish. He unvoted Zero and didn't vote anyone else, creating the whole situation. As a serial killer he would want as many people to be killed as possible. On top of that, whether he is Vigilante or Serial Killer, he has stated several times he does not know who he is going to vote for, and is just blind firing, which is likely to kill another town, as there are more towns then 3rd party and Mafia combined. 

How much Mafia experience do you have again?

The rest of your post is basically rewording what I originally said. But it's interesting that there's no tone suggesting you think I'm attacking you. Rather you're trying to convince me to look elsewhere... and then

DarkThanatos said:

theprof00 said:

There is a role that delays other players roles but it's rare.

Anyway, noc, now that you're here, you don't need to question radish. We already know he's scum, and I've devised that he's definitely an SK. We are keeping him around to thin out the mafia numbers, but we need to be careful that he doesn't start following his own win strategy.

I'm not sure thats the best action to take. There is no reason for Radish to kill off scum, because he knows if he targets scum they will just kill him. If he targets obvs town then we will just lynch him. He is stuck between a rock and a hard place. So I think he will either just blindfire, or target the people who are analysing everything and being active to generate confusion and cause mischief as he knows he almost definately won't win. So there's that, and then there is just the probability he will hit town anyway.

I agree Linkz is very suspicious and likely scum. I would happily vote for either of them. So for the moment 

Vote Radish 

But I'll change that to Linkz to finish him off. 

Pray tell. What makes me very suspicious. Why am I likely scum?