Top 10 games on Metacritic this gen, do you agree?

[Gilgamesh]

flagstaad said:

Gilgamesh said:
To be fair GTAIV was the first big sandbox game to arrive this gen and so the only thing it compared to was last gen games. That's why it got like perfect scores for graphics even though it's FAR from the best looking game this gen.

I don't agree with 2 titles on the list, but I have no idea with which ones should I replace them, I can only think in personal favorites not just great games. Since you started the thread can you help me with the 3 runner ups? places 11th to 13th, to see if those are better IMHO to those in the top ten?

11. Red Dead Redemption - PS3/X360

12. The legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess - Wii

13. Portal 2 - PC/PS3/X360

14. Call of duty: Modern Warfare 2 - PS3/X360

15. Batman: Arkham City - X360

16. Skyrim - PC