Torillian on 06 August 2012
Haven't played Lost Odyssey, Witcher 2, or Blue Dragon but from those I've played I'd have to go with Valkyria Chronicles as being best. If on the other hand the question was favorite I'd actually go with something not on your list: the Atelier series. Something about the gameplay of those titles really works for me, not the battle system but the time limit and synthesis are really a favorite from this gen for me.
...
