I like the Dualshock. I like it a lot.
I voted the second option, it just needs tweaking ever so slightly. Concave trigger buttons would be greatly appreciated. I don't have any problems with the D-Pad, but I wouldn't mind a new one either. Sometimes it's a little tricky picking the corner weapons on Starhawk.
It fits into my hands like I don't know what though. The 360 controller is too clunky for me, I don't think my hands are big enough for it.
I actually think the nicest controller I ever held was Gamecube. If it had had a proper second analogue stick (instead of that crappy c nub) then it may have been the best controller I ever used. edit: and a better start button too.







