By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Torillian on 22 June 2012
Edit Thread
happydolphin said:
Torillian said:

I disagree, the list just isn't all that accurate.  It contains a number of titles that are nowhere near confirmed (Persona 5 on PS3) and games that have no actual RPG aspects to them (Zelda, 3DDGH, can't think of any RPG aspects in Harvest Moon either, and Animal Crossing).  Yes he made a massive list but the validity for any real discussion is pretty weak.  Speaking as a JRPG fan who bought a Wii under the assumption that it would get the most, I can't agree with his list.  

His list is there for the Wii, and he was saying the Wii had more games than the PS3 so your point strengthens his. But you're discrediting the value of his list by pointing out non-confirmed PS3 titles. Any other gripes?

Be more specific, and if you were and that's all you had, then again, your gripe strengthens his point.

Also, you can't argue his numbers. What you can argue is the quality of the titles, but I've already done that for ya ;)

Again, I am arguing his numbers. Animal Crossing, Zelda, Harvest Moon, Monster Hunter, Zangeki no Reginleiv are all not RPGs, they have no rpg mechanics to them and cannot be counted in a list of JRPGs to prove which system has more JRPGs.  I was just pointing out that it's not just his Wii list, his PS3 list isn't correct either not only because of games that have no real release date (Persona 5 and FFV13) but games that again aren't RPGs (3DDGH, Monster Hunter)



...