| Kantor said: Just to address these two: 3) That thread has a poll in it, so I can see why it exists. It's also a highly specific discussion about sales for a very popular game. You don't really want discussions about sales and gameplay getting mixed up. The metascore thread didn't really need to exist, but this one does, I think. 4) If I may speak freely, the only reason Maxwell wasn't demodded was because ioi would likely have become annoyed, since he was appointed by ioi. |
3. Granted and agreed after speaking to yo_john. Sales threads definitely have their own place (in the Sales forum). The need for multiple sales threads about the same game - maybe less pronounced?
But my original point stands, and the consolidation of topics is a good thing. At this point, yo_john's thread is more appropriately a HYPE thread, albeit a gameplay-oriented one, and I don't think it necessary for there to be more than one of those at a time. The same will be true when the game comes out.
4. Understandable. Again, this point was only here to support 5.
