TWRoO said:
I have a hard time deciding between PoA and DH in terms of my favourite of the books. With the films I think PoA was the turnaround point: it's not a great film, but it's enjoyable in general and the kids acting, while still not good, is no longer atrocious as it is in the first two films. Books: DH/PoA > OotP > HBP/GoF > PS > CoS Films: DH1 > HBP > GoF > OotP > DH2 > PoA > PS > CoS As I may have mentioned earlier in this thread... I don't understand why the CoS film is so damn long (longest film for the shortest book) yet OotP is the shortest film for the longest book... particularly when there were plenty of things in the book that could have been cut out with no impact on the storyline, yet for some reason were taking up valuable screen time (e.g. Grawp) |
Somehow I agree on DH being the most intense book and DH1 being the best film. DH1 doesn't have such a convoluted story to tell and with it being half a book can take it's time, so that it doesn't have to skip over reasons and events.
