Mario Galaxy 2 (but also 1 was great)
Dragon Quest 4,5,6 remakes
Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney trilogy (and Apollo Justice)
Dragon Quest 9
Rune Factory series - Frontier in particular
Wii Sports
Just Dance series
Wii Fit
Animal Crossing Wild World
These are essentially all the games I will play in the future when this generation is forgotten - I just can't see myself replaying Final Fantasy 13, Mass Effect, Xenoblade, Zelda SS, or any of those games in the future. Maybe Pokemon.
I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.