happyD, I think you're off the beat here (is that the expression?)...
You shouldn't focus on the graphics - that's not what Mario is, or ever was, about (thu, they really did look awesome way back in the 80's!). They're about fun! And you can't judge that yet.
the thing I'm most dissapointed with with 2D mario is that it's not pushing any more limits! They used to show everyone what could be done! I don't feel like they've managed to do that since the early 90's. The same actually goes for Sonic: he's not popular any more cuz he's not relevant any more!
The reason for the NSMB-series popularity is in parts due to the fact that we hadn't had a 2D Mario when it came out to the DS, and that the Wii version gave you the coop option. But other than the coop Mario ain't pushing it in 2D any more! They're playing safe. THAT'S what you should be raging about happyD! Visuals don't make the game good.
I'm on Twitter @DanneSandin!
Furthermore, I think VGChartz should add a "Like"-button.
