I think it's safe to say the PS3 is the definitive graphics king for this gen

[Michael-5]

Aldro said:

Sal.Paradise said:

Michael-5 said:

 

 

As to your comment about KZ2..I believe you thought Aldro said KZ2 was the 4th best looking game after U3>U2>KZ3, but he corrected you and said that Gears 3 was in fact the fourth best looking game. I'd definitely agree with him on that! So no problems here.  

Nothing more to add but to clarify this.

 

No. I did not say KZ2 was the 4th best looking game. I did neither say Gears 3 was the 4th best looking game. I said GOD of WAR 3 was the 3RD best looking game followed by KZ3. (I refer to Gears as GeoW). I apologize for not making this clear.

All three of these have won >20 awards in their respective years 09,10,11. That was all I was ever trying to say and prove.

To me, personally, it is:

Uncharted 3 > Uncharted 2 > God of War III > Killzone 3 which I already said to Michael-5 is shockingly similar to the majority of the critics. He argues that the second is a toss up because it is too similar. I argue that the 4-5th can be a toss up because it is too similar. For me however, these 3-4 are in a league of their own. If I was to continue it'd be something like

>>> Gears of War 3 > Crysis 2 > Killzone 2 and i'll draw the line here.

Killzone 3 is a massive improvement over Killzone 2. I've platinum'd it and just like the first post on page 33 says, it really is miles ahead of KZ2. Rightfully so after 2 years. I still however hold the Uncharted franchise on top due to its insane engine that allows for sick setpieces and jaw dropping moments. God of War 3 is very very close aswell.

<3.

Shockingl similar to 1  website... just so you're clear at what you presented.

Anyway, the only difference between you and me is that your mix up takes place after 4 clear cut games, where mine is after #2 (I still think Gears 3 is #2, it lost to UC3)....and really Killzone 3? Even the guys at Digital Foundry said the difference between KZ3 and Crysis 2 was close, giving KZ3 the Win for cutscenes, and no screen tear.

Personally I still think Forza 4 and GT5 are the best, but GT5 has serious performance issues, and in both, your only modeling cars and some rocks/buildings..maybe a distant tree or two, where in UC3 and Gears 3, you're modeling water, fabric, human movement, and in the case of UC3, sand.

Either Way, it's not as if PS3 exclusives are by a significant volume, better looking then 360 exclusives. You say 4 PS3 exclusives look better then Gears 3, I say only 1 does. How many exclusives come out a year for both consoles? Far more then 4 (If you coun't PC iterations and Kinect exclusives for 360 LOL)

Debate concluded.