Obviously you're being reasonable, so I have no problems with you. Not that I agree with your opinion very much on this or FFXIII. :D
I agree in using the full 1-10 scale. However, you need to get the whole site on that train with you. Otherwise it makes you look like jim sterling. (Your review was much better than his review of FFXIII, though he had everyright to dislike it his review just sucked) But this site gave similar games, Resonance of Fate, and FFXIII an 8 and a 9 respectively and even Arc Rise of Fantasia a 6.
I know it's different reviewers but the truth is, I think people want to see a somewhat consistent scale so they can use scores to sort of compare games, atleast within a certain range. And FFXIII-2 is way off the range of 13, resonance of fate, and even Arc.
Now I'm not saying you should automatically score FF13-2higher, but I think if you haven't you should push this site to use the whole scale and not just you (which no matter how much they argues).
I'm 10 hours in and I really love it. (I actually thought the first hour or 2 was the worst part so far. But that's me).
Some of the problems you describe, aren't unique to this one imo. Characters that make little sense battle . The game being easy. It took me 15 hours to die once in FF9, Most of FF6, FF10 it took 30 hours before I died. Not that isn't a flaw, but it's a flaw I consider most FF's to have. But still, if it bothers you, it bothers you so I have no problem with you taking it off.
Also, hatmoza should quit hating the game before he plays it, or leave.