Well, in my games collection I have it rated as a 9.3, which is, on my rating scale, a notch below FFXIII and a notch above Red Dead Redemption, which is a very good score. When I look back at the game though, it does have some glaring issues, so I've been considering bumping down the score. Also, my ratings are too bunched up near the top end and need spacing out. When I've changed and readjusted everything, I think Uncharted 3's score will come out at a 8.9/10, so put me down for that.
Uncharted 3 was a great game, but it had its issues. It didn't feel as fresh as the first two, it had poor pacing, it abandoned all story development about halfway through and wasted a lot of potential and it started to get repetitive after a while.
Still, it is the best looking game this generation, it had some epic moments, especially the plane and desert section, holy shit, it was a fun ride and the characters were hilarious.
So yeah, 8.9/10, GOTY for me.
