SMRPG vs. Paper Mario vs. Mario and Luigi

[Runa216]

Spazzy_D said:

Runa216 said:
I think the thing that bothers me more is the fact that Paper Mario is beating mario RPG, and a lot of people consider Mario RPG to be inferior to all other games in the poll...like what the hell?  Normally I'm all for people having their opinions, but that's just wrong! 

Mario RPG is a classic, one of the best games of all time, the Paper Mario and Mario and Luigi are GOOD, but not even in the same league. 

I voted Paper Mario.....  but I love Super Marior RPG more.  It was a great game at the time....  but it has NOT aged well.  I think Paper Mario is more timeless and unique, that's why it got the nod.

I have the feeling that most of the people that dislike SMRPG are younger, it just really feels dated compared to the other two series and if you played them all for the first time today you would probably agree.

How in the world has Mario RPG not aged well?  It still looks and plays damn near perfect.  The controls are smoothe, the game is the perfect length, the graphics and sound are impeccable (and look better than a lot of modern games).  How has it not aged well?