Would a 3D Ipad do better than the 3DS?

[sethnintendo]

kowenicki said:

only due to the ipad 3 release.  ipad 2 will sell more in the time ipad 2 and 3ds are concurrently on sale.

Apple can never lose if you compare one of their models selling against another competitor's product considering a lot of Apple fans buy every new iteration no matter how little the change.  Not only is it an unfair comparison to begin with (tablet vs hand held) but it is even more so if you factor in your stipulations.