I'm going to comment in here as I've played Skyward Sword. I've had ZERO, Absolutely ZERO issues with the motion controls. There are only a couple negatives in that Gamespot review that even make sense. The rest are just imagined by the reviewer who obviously didn't want to even try to play the game, I bet since it wasn't an FPS or a first person game in general. Maybe it was because it was on the Wii, and it wasn't hardcore enough for him.