Gamespot gives The Legend of Zelda:Skyward sword a.........

[Moren]

Game Informer is usually harsh on Nintendo... they gave it a 10.
EDGE is usually very harsh... they gave it a 10.
Eurogamer gave it a 10.
Famitsu (even if they lost a lot of credibility) gave it a 40/40.
IGN gave it a 10.

Those are the reviews I will trust.