In the graphics department, I'll give to Uncharted. There's no game that can touch Uncharted 3 when it comes to lighting and shading add their stage setup that moves around, I don't think there is anything right now that can match it. Coop, I'll give to Gears, hands down, hell I'll give it to the first Gears over Uncharted 3. As far as gameplay is concerned, I'll give to Uncharted 3, Gears becomes repetitive after the first 10 minutes, especially in Gears 3 where there isn't a break (Which isn't a bad thing). But where Uncharted series thrives, is how they change up the gameplay. Whether it be in the first game where you have to run and gun against zombies, hoping from train to train, or trying to aim while a cargo ship is spinning around; Naughty Dog just takes third person shooting, and takes it to its limits. Naughty Do will find a way to make the game fresh, that's something Epic just doesn't do (Though it doesn't make sense to do that since platforming wouldn't make sense in Gears).
