IGN - Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception Review!!!

[Michael-5]

pezus said:

Michael-5 said:

2. UC3's metascore is 94/100, which is actually 2 points below Uncharted 2. I think it's safe to say many people will agree with me. IGN is giving 10/10's too easily. I would have been happy if they just gave 9.8/10, which is still high, but it's a good game.

3. Last point about UC MP.. Any game with a score 9/10 or greater has better MP then Uncharted, and I'm being lenient. Killzone, Call of Duty, Grand Theft Auto, Battlefield 3, even Bioshock 2.

2. *Facepalm* IGN only rate on a 20 point scale, they changed it some time ago. You can imagine that UC3 is a 9.8 game if you want, it would still have got a 10 from IGN.

3. That's just bullshit and you know it. You said it yourself, you have played it for 20 MINUTES. Bioshock 2 has crappy multiplayer; you most likely have not even played BF3; GTA multiplayer wasn't very good; Killzone's and Call of Duty's multiplayer is very good though. 

2. That' a stupid system to use. So if the score were 97, would it be rounded to 95/100? How come some games still get score of 94/100?

This actually supports my arguement, IGN's rating system is seriously flawed.

3. I played BF3 on my friends PC, it's fun, and I used to play a little BF2, so I have something to get it to. Bioshock multiplayer was decent, like UC3, GTAIV multiplayer, again decent.

I didn't want to include 360 exclusives to the debate, lets ignore all the above titles, you still agree Killzone and CoD multiplayer is better then UC3? Is it a big difference for you?

As for your IMDB comment, good call, guess that's like the user score on a website, or metacritic. Still IGN should make reviews which respresent them as a company. If an individual gives a game a 10/10, and they want that to represent the website as a whole, they should have othr people look over it. The individuals who review games at IGN seem to give 10/10 out too easily this gen.

That said, Uncharted 3 could be the most deserving title for 10/10, but then MGS4, SMG2, and GTAIV should not have gotten 10/10. There is only room for one pinnacle game every gen, it's hardly a pinnacle of gaming if one of these games come out every year.

This is my arguement, people need to stop attacking me for my view on Uncharted, and stop twisting my arguement to whatever they feel like. I say good and bad things about all games, and I will defend games which I feel are disrespected. If people talked about Uncharted the way they do about Forza 4, I would do the exact same thing (as soon as I play UC3) on this thead as I did the other.

Read the IGN review. It says the game is 8 hours long, and Uncharted 2 is 10 hours. "The game is give or take about 10 hours in length, which feels right.."-UC2 In the UC3 video review they say the game is 8 hours.

Wait your right, Portal 2 and Forza 4 got 9.5 on IGN, along with Mass Effect 2 (PS3). My mistake, got the websites mixed up, I admit when I'm wrong. However 94/100 for Forza 4 and 90/100 for Portal 2 are still fair scores. GT also gave GT5 a 90/100 where IGN gave it an 85/100.

osama your hilarious. You are show incredible bias. Only me? Maybe on this website, but it's not only me. This website also lacks people who own more then just a PS3. Look at the metascore, read the reviews, not everyone thinks so highly of UC3 multiplayer. The same goes with many franchises, but I honestly feel UC3 multiplayer is acked on. It reminds me of Resident Evil 5 Versus.

My whole arguement is no game should get 10/10, and IGN should really change their rating system if 9.5 is the highest legitimate score they can give. IGN is flawed, that's my arguement, stop twisting it around to be something else. I am also an Uncharted fan, so ignoring me, and forcing an image onto me.

If you want to just sit around mock me, go ahead, but you are not worth debating with if that's the path you choose. So far, that appears to be your goal. Accept other people have different opinions, and move on. If you want to debate with me, debate with the arguement I am presenting, stop making an arguement up yourself.