Are they idiots? Yes, some of them are but if those were the 5 silliest comments you could find its not really that bad at all imo. I've seen much, much worse.
Is it a bad score? I haven't played it myself but suspect I'm going to love it just like the two first, which by no means makes this review unfair. Everyone has different tastes, I'd probably review some pretty high scoring games a lot lower. And, besides; an 8 is not a poor score, its the same old thing this gen, reviewers shell out 9's and 10's everywhere and people start whining when games get scored "average" at 8's...







