By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I would go with Mario Galaxy. Super Paper Mario is a fun and interesting concept, but unfortunately gets bogged down by the pointless story and endless amounts of text. Of course if you don't mind that you may want to give it a look, but personally that drove me nuts. Galaxy, while it isn't the most fun Mario platformer, is a solid game, and at least cuts most of the story BS and gets right into the action.