By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Amnesia, hands down.

That game terrified me. I don't even know if scared is the right word.
It was beyond being "startled" or surprised, or anything. It outright crept me out to my very core. It was never more tempting to ramp up the brightness to max settings on a game before.

 

I was fine with Dead Space. I mean, something would jump at me but at most - I'd be startled. If I can shoot something in the face, I tend to be less scared of it.