First few chapters of Dead Space scared the crap outta me, but after a while I got use to the style and the atmosphere and it wasn't so scary anymore, overall I think the first Condemned is better (2nd one is mehish).
Siren: Blood Curse is pretty good, I know people that have completed both Dead Space and Condemned would not finish it, but I'm a slut when it comes to Asian style horrors and I can take them from all sides, so it doesn't scare me that much, same goes for Fatal Frame 4.
Haven't tried Dead Space 2 or Metro, F.E.A.R games made me laugh, Amnesia was weird like shit and I gave up after 30 minutes or so, just don't enjoy that kind of game.
Overall from the games I've played:
1. Condemned: Criminal Origins
2. Tied between Siren: Blood Curse and Dead Space
3. Fatal Frame 4
