Sales=Quality

[Torillian]

DeadNotSleeping said:

God of War and Uncharted 2 have succeeded in entertaining you.  So your subjective opinion is that they are better.  However, they have failed to entertain as many people as Mario, ergo Mario is objectively better.  Personally, I liked Uncharted 2 better, but that's just me.  I'm a little outnumbered on this planet.

See though, you have a meaningful opinion because you played both and found one better.  On the other hand you can't just look at sales numbers and say that equates with which is better because all those people didn't play both and make a decision, they just bought the genre they wanted, platform they had, and game they heard about.  I doubt many of those sales equate to someone who actually got to try both and make a fully informed decision about which was better and those would be the only sales I would count as a reasonable measure of quality.