*Best HD Third Party Elimination Game*

[Michael-5]

Jay520 said:

Michael-5 said:

You voted AC and Mass Effect down because they were leading, which is still within the rules, but IMO a bit unsporting.

That's kind of the point of elimination games. Why would he vote down games games that were already losing to Bioshock? Most people vote down the leading games so their game can win.

He did the same thing most people did. They voted down the game that would be the most competition to their favorites. I don't see how that's unsporting. And whos to say he doesn't like AC & ME as much as Batman & Portal.

I'll admit, I wish Mass Effect would have won, but hey, people didn't want to see it win over their favorite franchise.

Yea, that's true, but it's a bit unfair. I only went straight negative on Bioshock at the end because it was the worst game on the list IMO. If you look back, only when Street Fighter was a death row did I start to vote down Bioshock, and only at the end did I start to straight vote Mass Effect.

It's no fun when some people vote the same over and over, you shouldn't vote just so one specific game you like makes it to the top, but so the top positions are populated with games you like. Hence why I pushed Vanquish hard before, and others.