By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I think this rule edit here will make everyone the happiest.

2. If you score a game 4 or more points above or below a game's metacritic average then you must go into great detail as to why you did so.

What do you think? I personally think this is the best possible way to do this especially when dealing with games that aren't as good.

So with this rule change Carl's score wouldn't count and neither would morenoingrato's