By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Boutros on 11 August 2011
Edit Thread
Soriku said:
Boutros said:
Soriku said:
Antabus said:
It will be lucky to get over 80.


lol. Well of course you'd say that when you know absolutely nothing about the game. You know the game is the highest rated RPG this gen on Japan's biggest user review site right with a 90% right?

http://neogaf.net/forum/showthread.php?t=422089

Riiiight and FFXIII gets a 60 and Oblivion gets a 60 and Fallout 3 a 56...Even The Last Story is at 58 (behind Arc Rise Fantasia and Opoona LOL). And I could go on and on.

Even Famitsu is more reliable than this website.

...

Uhh...what are you talking about? Fallout 3 has an 82, Obvlivion has a 79. Those are right there in the link I provided! What crazy numbers are you looking at? No, really, how did you get these numbers? Shows that you didn't read. Why don't you read duckroll's explanation on the site to know why it's reliable?

For FF XIII we know the game has very mixed impressions WW, not just in Japan. Even in Amazon Japan the game has 3 stars. How strange that it's exactly the same as this site...and Amazon isn't even is a moderated as this one. Whether you really like FF XIII or not doesn't change the fact that the game received mixed impressions overall.

And I don't see what's so strange about Arc Rise Fantasia being higher than TLS. TLS has some has some very mixed impressions as well if you read some reviews. And the only reasons ARF is bashed is because of the voice acting which isn't a problem in Japan. Other than that, it's a very good game. Remember that review I wrote a while back? Opoona is the only strange one (I guess people just liked it more than we think).

And don't you think Xenoblade's score on that site seems awfully similar to the reviews thus far? And like Rol said, German/Austrian reviewers aren't the most favorable people, and a site that doesn't like the Wii like GamePro STILL gave the game an 87% which is very good.

http://www.psmk2.net/title.php?title=575

http://www.psmk2.net/title.php?title=517

I hadn't seen the original release but why are these so low still? I think that website is filled with trolls.

And those were just a couple of examples. I could give you more but I fear you're going to find a clever explanation for all of them O_o

 

Also the sole reason why FFXIII is that low is simply because it went to the 360. Famitsu readers voted FFXIII the best game of all time so spare me the mixed impressions stuff. It wasn't the same in Japan.

 

But you are right the website gives us a good indication of Xenoblade's quality but it is not to be taken too seriously as it seems like some games are inflated for no reason and some other are overly underrated.