Dgc1808 on 10 August 2011
My first vote in this thread. I've played both games extensively and platinum'd GoW3. My vote goes to MGS4.
While it relied heavily on the previous titles for one to really appreciate the story, i still enjoyed the MGS4 story more. I actually cared about the main cast which is quite the opposite with GoW. Gameplay was also much more engaging and featured numerous improvements from it's prequals while GoW can be seen as more of the same. Don't get me wrong. I liked GoW3. Was a really epic experience but I just don't think it was as epic as any of the MGS games, especially 4 or 3.
4 ≈ One
