Head to Head

[Michael-5]

CGI-Quality said:

Michael-5 said:

Maybe we could make our own serial killer and have multiplayer matchmaking where everyone tries to kill each other. The trick is when you attack or dodge, you have to follow one of the button sequence events.

You are right, this vote is like comparing Apples to Oranges, but that Halo Orange is a big Orange. Halo should out vote Heavy Rain, not because it's a better game (both are excellent), but because as a $60 purchase, you get more out of Halo. For the same reason I would expect Halo to out vote Alan Wake, and I would expect GT to do the same as Halo.

Obviously some people not a fan of the FPS franchise should vote Heavy Rain, especially those who replayed the game multipler times. However this is the best selling HD exclusive were talking about here, it's should be outclassed by a game which sells a fifth as many units. Quality aside, when you're hungry, the big Orange will be more appealing then the small tasty Apple.

I think dsage made this comparision to get a 360 game to win against a PS3 title, but clearly, since many people don't own a 360 here, they probably just instinctivly vote the PS3 game.

I think you'd be surprised how many more people own 360s on this site than people assume.

Well maybe people do, and I am being a bit rough on the PS3 (it's a great system deserving of a large fanbase), but most multi-console owners here likely bought a PS3 before a 360 (opposite of me).

CGI Said:

dsage01 said:
Gosh poor Micheal 5 getting in an argument with every one. No one really tries to understand what the guy is saying. Anyways Heavy Rain winning 41-28!! Now I have to admit this is getting really biased. So now I will do PS3 vs PS3 games and 360 vs 360 games (oh wait only one is going through). But almost everyone I know doesn't like Heavy Rain at all. Yet it still tends to crush Halo Reach which people claim (best FPS ever). I can grantee you the 41 people who voted Heavy Rain out of that half of the people haven't played the game but just cause they own a PS3 they vote for that game. Gosh this is really sad. I think maybe I should make a multiplat comparison ex: Assassin's Creed Brotherhood vs Red Dead Redemption so it will be a lot more fair

I don't think you can complain much about the results. Besides the fact that some of these comparisons just didn't make any sense,  there's not much that should be too shocking here (mainly because, again, you see the site as so Sony biased). Why create a topic asking for people's opinions and then frown when one side isn't favored in the votes? How do you know 41 people didn't like and/or played HR or whatever other title they voted for?

When you do threads like this, you should exercise a little more flexibility. Otherwise, it comes off as you just doing these comparisons to spark flames.

Michael-5: How do you guys doublt quote?

;-( for arguements against me.

I think dsage had good intentions comparing PS3 to 360 exclusives, but for any leftover votes, or threads. You should compare games within that console, or compare multiplatform games to each other. The only reason why this Sony biased website stuff is comming into play is because dsage is shocked at how much most of the votes lean towards PS3 games. We all expected PS3 games to win most of the time, but if the only AAA game a 360 exclusive can beat is Resistance, then it's sad that people don't appreciate the 360 exclusives very much here.

*sign* stares at Lost Odyssey and Tales of Vesperia...... ;-(