You can only get 1 holiday 2011 title. What would it be?

[Torillian]

I'd have to go with Twisted Metal, I want something to play with my friends and we have enough shooters already so I could sacrifice Uncharted 3 and still have something to play but I don't really have anything like Twisted Metal already.

If I were being selfish and not taking them into account I'd go Dark Souls.