Head to Head

[Michael-5]

Reasonable said:

Michael-5 said:

dsage01 said:
What should I put Uncharted 2 up against? Any ideas

Whatever you put it against, that game WILL loose. The only fair comparision is Mass Effect 2, and despite IGN making an article explaining why ME2 got better ratings and is a better game, that will still loose, by a long shot.

Uncharted 2 is PS3's best exclusive, and on a PS3 favoring site, it has no competition. So I say do...

Uncharted 2 vs. MGS4 or Uncharted 3 vs. Killzone 3.

 

That's the only way any game has a fair chance.

Given the goal is to allow people to vote for PS3 vs 360 exclusives, that makes no sense.  Also, IGN hardly outweighs all the other critical reviews for Uncharted 2.

The bottom line is critically Uncharted 2 is arguably the best game (never mind exclusive) this generation so logically you would expect it to beat most stuff.  Personally I think it should have gone up against Reach but that's not an option now.  Note I'm not saying it is the best game, just that one look at Metacritic and the list of awards it won indicates it might just really be that good.

OT for current vote I'll go with Killzone 2.  I really like L4D but find Killzone 2 overall more interesting and I was one of the crazy folk who actually liked the way it handled movement with a real a sense of weight.  Close one but Killzone 2 just pips it.

Uncharted 2 and Mass Effect 2 are both damn great games. Best of the generation, but Mass Effect 2 should come close to beating UC2 in a vote. UC2 shouldn't be garenteed a win.

Logically UC2 will beat anything here, but if the fanbase were even Mass Effect 2 and Halo 3 should have stood a better chance.