The site you're talking about is owned by a Battlefield fan (or Call of Duty hater) and EA doesn't have anything to do with it.
Regarding the games themselves, I don't care for online shooting and thus I will be happy by only renting both and playing the single player campaign. However, Battlefield appears to be much better but Call of Duty should be good enough, especially if, unlike CoD:MW2, the plot makes any sense this time.







