Explain to me how PS3 and Wii had better E3 than 360

[Michael-5]

thx1139 said:

I am talking about everything that went on at E3 not just the press conferences.

OK so I was on vacation last week and only paid partial attention to E3. I have watched the MS E3 presentation and seen many of the other 360 announcements made by MS and others post the presentation.  If it wasnt shown, but we know its coming I will not mention it. I wont mention multiplatform (I dont mean what may show up on PC) even if they have console specific features.

For 360 I see the following showcased titles (all week)

Gears 3 - September 2011
Forza 4 - October 2011
Halo CE Anniversary - November 2011
Halo 4 - 2012
Dance Central 2 - Holiday 2011
Kinect Sports 2 - Holiday 2011
Kinect Star Wars - Holiday 2011
Kinect Disneyland Adventures - November 2011
Ryse - 2012
Fable: The Journey - 2012
Minecraft - Winter 2011 - XBL, not really a full game, but anyone I know who's played minecraft keep telling me it is.
Rise of Nightmares - Fall 2011 - No info at E3 (at least I didn't see any for the Japanese Kinect titles, Project Draco, Steel Batallion, Codename D, etc)
Sesame Street - Fall 2011
XCOM - 2012 Not exclusive anymore
The Witcher 2 - Fall 2011

New voice enabled Metro UI 360 dashboard with youtube, ufc, live tv, bing enabled integrated content search. New Xbox Live features include cloud storage, beacons.

Many new XBLA titles.

So I contrast that with the stuff I heard about for PS3 and Wii.

Wii
New Zelda - Fall 2011
New Kirby - Fall 2011
Mario Party 9 - Fall 2011
Fortune Quest - Fall 2011
More games are coming, but not shown at E3. The Last Story, XenoBlade, DQX, Pikmin 3 (I hope still)

PS3
Resistance 3 - Fall 2011
Uncharted 3 - Fall 2011
Twisted Metal - Fall 2011
Starhawk - 2012
Sly Cooper 4 - 2012
PSP God of War titles packaged for PS3
ICO Collection - Fall 2011
The Last Guardian (but I didn't see it at E3)
Dust 514 - 2012
Medevil Moves - Fall 2011
Sorcery - Fall 2011
Disgaea 4 - Fall 2011
Dragon's Crown - Fall 2011
Ruin - Fall 2011
As far as I know nothing new for PSN.

 

So what did I miss?  

I've been through this so many times already, but I'm glad to see people agree with you that 360 was the best, largely because of Halo 4.

I also agree, but 360 only beats PS3 realy because of Halo 4. However your list isn't quite accurate, so let me expand. You missed a lot of PS3 games.

So 13 games for the Wii (plus a handful of Japanese Kinect games we will likely learn more about at TGS), but it includes 2 <5 kids games and an XBL game. PS3 has 14 games, but the only not talked about game was The Last Guardian, so if we include the Japanese Kinect games, 360 has slightly more. Of those 14 games, 2 are ports.

Of all those games, MS has 4 AAA games, and PS3 has 2 AAA games coming out, not to say that smaller budget or Kinect/Move games won't be fun.

So IMO, 360 beat PS3 which crushed Wii, but without Halo 4 I would not have given the title to 360.