Rate Sony 2011 E3

[Michael-5]

osamanobama said:

Michael-5 said:

osamanobama said:

michael this is not a personal attack. 

this is a completely serious question; Do you  really not see how hypocritical you are? 

if you really dont, i suggest you go back and reflect on previous arguements youve had with me as well as others. im sure with time it will become faily evident that your essay have an abundance of contridictions, and false claims and misrepresentations of what others have said.

also one last tip, just as the GOW collection got a graphical overhaul, and as Halo 1 is too, so is the GOW PSP collection. and what other platform is DUST on, as far as i know its exclusive. another tip, the games you said i  claimed were AAA and the games you cliamed were AA, i didnt, read back please, i didnt claim any games to be AAA.

i tried to put this in as civil of a way as possible, but its still rather unfortunate that you dont see your hypocrasy.

You ignore my post and call me names, and I'm the one who isn;t making a fair debate?

Last arguement we had you came back to me an apoligized because you yourself realized you were being insulting.

GOW PSP is a port, with 3D graphics. The game using the same engine as the PSP interation, just upgraded slightly for PS3. Halo CE is completly redone, and runs on a different engine. It's also including multiplayer, something the original version never had (PC version did).

Dust 514 is also comming out to 360. What the PS3 version has is cross platform play with PC (just like Portal 2). This is big for a MMO, but Dust 514 is not a PS3 exclusive. Go to IGN.com and you will see it is listed as a 360 game too.

I only claimed HAlo's as AAA. You said that I claimed Ryse was AAA, but Medevil Moves (similar quality) was not, therefor I'm hypocritical. I return to you that neither were AAA.

Please, read my posts before replying. I think the reason why you think I am hypocritical is because you are labeling me as a 360 fanboy (in your head), and taking what I have to say in an extremly biased way. All I am claiming is what MS's 360 show was better because they showed more good-decent games (4 PS3 compared to 6 360), and that only MS showed AAA titles (2 Halo games). You might not be a fan of Dance Central, but in reality it will get a similar rating as Sly Cooper. Might not be a "core" game, but it's still fun as hell. Ryse, Fable, and Sly may be fun, but they are nowhere nearly as appealing to the masses as Halo, or major 3rd party multiplatformers like Batman, so the only AAA HD exclusives were the 2 Halo's simple.

There are no contradictions to my points, you just twist what I have to say until there is. I never claimed Ryse was AAA, but Medevil Moves was not, you made that up, among other things.

You are trying to be civil, but in this comment, you did not do one thing but critisize. That is far from civil, that's just insulting. If you want to be civil, leave the namecalling out.

i dont know why im doing this, but what the hell...

i never claimed that either the medevil game or Ryse were AAA, nor did i claim you did. just wanted to clarify that.

if you are counting a remastered 10 year old game, as a AAA title no less then you must also include a remastered game that has been overhauled to have better graphics, 3D capabilities and other bells and whistles. GOW is just as much of a AAA title as Halo 1.

aslo when did i ever name call you, did you just make that up, really where did i do that? i was being very civil. it seems you read things how you want to see them, and ignore things that you want to ignore

I know your a nice guy, so lets start from sratch. I never, past points, this is just stupid.

I feel MS's announced more games for the 360 then Sony did for the PS3, and because of that I feel the MS press conference was better. Yea Sony talked about Uncharted and Resistance, but to me that completly cancels out with Gears and Forza. They did talk about InFamous 2, but that's already out so it's not really an upcoming game to look forward to, and Twisted Metal/The Last Guardian were nowhere to be seen.

So I feel MS's 360 press conference was better then Sony's PS3 portion of their conference.

Ryse, Fable, Dance Central 2, Kinect Sports 2, Starhawk, Dragon's Crown (ethomaz pointed this one out to me), God of War Origins Collection, Sly Cooper, and Medevil Moves all look good- decent. They all depend on specific tastes.

However MS announced 2 AAA titles. Halo CE, and Halo 4. Now I know you want to argue God of War Origins collection is AAA, but it's not. AAA has nothing to do with quality, or how big a game is, it has to do with how much money is spent with Production. Uncharted is a AAA game because the entire Naughty Dog studios devote themselves basically to this one game at a time. Same goes with Resistance, Gears of War, Forza, Fable (maybe not the Kinect one), GT, Killzone, and God of War. However Origins collection is a ported game, modifiest to take advantage of the PS3. This is not a game that's been 2 years or so in the making, Halo 1 remake is the first game 343 Studios is making, and it's likely been in production since before Reach (along with Halo 4).

So overall, the number of newly announced games is similar, 6 to 5. However 360 has 2 AAA games, Sony has Zero. Even if you don't want to count Halo CE as AAA (which is fair, I don't count Twisted Metal as AAA), it's still 1 AAA game on 360 and 0 on Sony. So 360 was better then PS3, maybe not for everyone (some people really dislike Halo/Kinect), but overall it was better. This is not my opinion, I am just counting the number of games, and showing 360 was better.

P.S. You didn't name call, but you made several attempts to demean me. Saying that "arguing with someone like me" or replying and saying my entire post made no sence and has contradictrions all over itself, so it shouldn't be listened to is demeaning. You were trying to win your debate, not by debating, but by claiming my points were basically stupid and wrong.